Deleted
•
Posts: 0
Likes:
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 20, 2017 17:00:14 GMT
This question kinda goes back to "Rock In The Road". But I'm assuming Judith is being watched by Carl now. But when they were gone. Who was watching Judith? An Alexandrian. Gabe swore to protect her and he just left with the hooded man. Why didn't Rick at least ask? I thought it would be addressed. But I assume she's fine. Seems like this season we have to assume alot.
|
|
|
pepper
•
Walker Food
Posts: 15
Likes: 5
|
Post by pepper on Feb 20, 2017 17:20:21 GMT
This question kinda goes back to "Rock In The Road". But I'm assuming Judith is being watched by Carl now. But when they were gone. Who was watching Judith? An Alexandrian. Gabe swore to protect her and he just left with the hooded man. Why didn't Rick at least ask? I thought it would be addressed. But I assume she's fine. Seems like this season we have to assume alot. This is off subject....but it reminded me when you said we have to assume. When it showed Carol sitting by the fire and Daryl at the table...I was thinking, oh please tell me he did not tell her off screen. That moment deserves to be shown!!!! Then he didn't tell her at all. Lol
|
|
|
wickedjenИ
•
Chris Evan's Wife
Forager
Posts: 269
Likes: 218
Gender: Female
|
Post by wickedjenИ on Feb 20, 2017 17:25:03 GMT
Judith is a constant afterthought, it amazes me sometimes.
I can't remember, but does Rick know about Negan's interaction with her? I didn't think he did.
|
|
|
danae
•
I have Jesus inside me.
Global Moderator
Posts: 1,796
Likes: 1,177
Gender: Female
|
Post by danae on Feb 20, 2017 17:29:05 GMT
Well first of all Rick knows that Judith is safe and sound, he had returned to Alexandria prior to leaving again in search of Gabe. He would not have left Alexandria (on his quest to find Gabriel) without making sure that both she and Carl were okay. Yes, this bit is an assumption, but I tend to think a safe assumption.
I also do not think that Gabe's role is to always protect Judith. I do think that in specific instances (taking her to the church during the onslaught of walkers NWO and also when they left to take Maggie to Hilltop) Gabriel steps up to the plate and offers in that moment to protect her. When Negan returns with Carl it is Olivia who is caring for Judith - so Gabe is not always her go to caregiver in the absence of Rick.
Also we did find out last night that Gabriel did not willingly leave with the hooded person so it is not exactly accurate to say that "he just left with the hooded man".
|
|
|
lookitsrick
•
Forager
Posts: 221
Likes: 69
Gender: Female
|
Post by lookitsrick on Feb 20, 2017 17:54:33 GMT
I think Aaron was watching Judith in 709
|
|
|
Deleted
•
Posts: 0
Likes:
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 20, 2017 18:12:54 GMT
This question kinda goes back to "Rock In The Road". But I'm assuming Judith is being watched by Carl now. But when they were gone. Who was watching Judith? An Alexandrian. Gabe swore to protect her and he just left with the hooded man. Why didn't Rick at least ask? I thought it would be addressed. But I assume she's fine. Seems like this season we have to assume alot. This is off subject....but it reminded me when you said we have to assume. When it showed Carol sitting by the fire and Daryl at the table...I was thinking, oh please tell me he did not tell her off screen. That moment deserves to be shown!!!! Then he didn't tell her at all. Lol Haha I thought this too! But he lied to her in the end.
|
|
|
Deleted
•
Posts: 0
Likes:
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 20, 2017 18:22:30 GMT
Well first of all Rick knows that Judith is safe and sound, he had returned to Alexandria prior to leaving again in search of Gabe. He would not have left Alexandria (on his quest to find Gabriel) without making sure that both she and Carl were okay. Yes, this bit is an assumption, but I tend to think a safe assumption. I also do not think that Gabe's role is to always protect Judith. I do think that in specific instances (taking her to the church during the onslaught of walkers NWO and also when they left to take Maggie to Hilltop) Gabriel steps up to the plate and offers in that moment to protect her. When Negan returns with Carl it is Olivia who is caring for Judith - so Gabe is not always her go to caregiver in the absence of Rick. Also we did find out last night that Gabriel did not willingly leave with the hooded person so it is not exactly accurate to say that "he just left with the hooded man". Thanks for your response. But the the dialogue isn't realistic anymore. Did Tara mention to anyone about Heath? No It must be mentioned off screen then about him. I agree that Rick/Michonne would want Carl/Judith safe. That is a good assumption. I didn't write that correctly but you are right he does step up when needed. Other people have watched Jessie, other Alexandrians, and Oliva. I know Gabe didn't up and leave, again thanks for correcting me but that isn't what I meant. It looked like he was knocked out and forced to go by the Hooded Person.
|
|
|
danae
•
I have Jesus inside me.
Global Moderator
Posts: 1,796
Likes: 1,177
Gender: Female
|
Post by danae on Feb 20, 2017 18:39:25 GMT
I am of the opinion that we do not need to have every little thing touched upon in order to have the dialogue deemed as realistic. Staying with the point of contention regarding Heath, it is a safe assumption that of course Tara spoke with them about the absence of Heath. I just do not see it as a point of declaration that needs to have any of our 42 minutes of actual air time spent on. Just last episode the exchange between Morgan, Rick and Daryl about what happened to Carol was just minutes long - an in depth play by play of what transpired was not needed. Her character supports having some exploration of where she is. In comparison, Heath's character is secondary and not necessary to the plot point at this time, no reason to spend precious on air time discussing that he is missing.
The writers have a limited amount of air time to tell the best story they can about the characters actually involved in driving that story forward.
|
|
|
PepperAnn
•
Ginger FOHEVAAH
Administrator
Posts: 1,136
Likes: 562
|
Post by PepperAnn on Feb 20, 2017 18:58:21 GMT
I am of the opinion that we do not need to have every little thing touched upon in order to have the dialogue deemed as realistic. Staying with the point of contention regarding Heath, it is a safe assumption that of course Tara spoke with them about the absence of Heath. I just do not see it as a point of declaration that needs to have any of our 42 minutes of actual air time spent on. Just last episode the exchange between Morgan, Rick and Daryl about what happened to Carol was just minutes long - an in depth play by play of what transpired was not needed. Her character supports having some exploration of where she is. In comparison, Heath's character is secondary and not necessary to the plot point at this time, no reason to spend precious on air time discussing that he is missing. The writers have a limited amount of air time to tell the best story they can about the characters actually involved in driving that story forward. I agree. There are really only two things that should have happened on camera. One was telling Tara about Denise, Abe and Glenn. Still pissed about that. And the other hasn't happened yet but better be on camera. Telling Carol.
|
|
|
jen
•
Blowing bubble come
Walker Food
Posts: 48
Likes: 91
Gender: Female
|
Post by jen on Feb 20, 2017 22:06:15 GMT
Deadbeat dad.
|
|
|
danae
•
I have Jesus inside me.
Global Moderator
Posts: 1,796
Likes: 1,177
Gender: Female
|
Post by danae on Feb 20, 2017 22:57:44 GMT
Deadbeat dad.
|
|
|
PepperAnn
•
Ginger FOHEVAAH
Administrator
Posts: 1,136
Likes: 562
|
Post by PepperAnn on Feb 20, 2017 23:04:02 GMT
Deadbeat dad. Cracked me up. LOL
|
|
|
|
Post by Thales Targaryen on Feb 20, 2017 23:05:47 GMT
I am of the opinion that we do not need to have every little thing touched upon in order to have the dialogue deemed as realistic. Staying with the point of contention regarding Heath, it is a safe assumption that of course Tara spoke with them about the absence of Heath. I just do not see it as a point of declaration that needs to have any of our 42 minutes of actual air time spent on. Just last episode the exchange between Morgan, Rick and Daryl about what happened to Carol was just minutes long - an in depth play by play of what transpired was not needed. Her character supports having some exploration of where she is. In comparison, Heath's character is secondary and not necessary to the plot point at this time, no reason to spend precious on air time discussing that he is missing. The writers have a limited amount of air time to tell the best story they can about the characters actually involved in driving that story forward. Yeah agreed, there's better ways to spend those precious TV minutes than talk about every little detail. Game of Thrones fans complain a lot about this one character travelling constantly, and we never get to see it, so people joke that he teleports. I really don't see the point of showing every character's travels if there's no story during it, there's no point to that. Some things just happen off-camera.
|
|
|
weallgotit
•
Walker Hunter
Posts: 679
Likes: 338
Gender: Male
|
Post by weallgotit on Feb 21, 2017 4:54:01 GMT
I think it's just another one of the statements that should have been made or scenes that should have been shown but weren't. It would have been nice to see them as viewers because we see all of the events and want everything to come together to seem realistic. But we know everything does not need to be shown to tell the main core of the story or parts of it. So things like this are often not shown and we do have to expectations that they happened off screen.
|
|
|